Back to Blog

Ready to get Started?

Experience 100% ethical web data collection with Massive’s advanced proxy solutions.

Sign Up Now
a visual description of a ISP vs Residential Proxies

ISP Proxies vs Residential Proxies: Choosing the Right Proxy

Jason Grad
Proxy Network Manager
May 30, 2024

Navigating the world of proxies can be tricky, this concise guide will cover essential topics for you to choose the correct proxy types for your needs. For those wondering "Which is more cost effective for my use case?", "What proxy network is better for a high frequency of concurrent requests?", "What are the advantages of each network type?", this was written for you.

Topics Covered: Whether you're looking at rotating IP addresses or avoiding IP bans, this article will help make your options clear.


           <li><a href="#isp">What are ISP proxies?</a></li>

           <li><a href="#residential">What are Residential proxies?</a></li>

           <li><a href="#isp_use_case">What are advantages and disadvantages of ISP proxies?</a></li>

           <li><a href="#residential_use_case">What are the advantages and disadvantages of Residential proxies?</a></li>

           <li><a href="#comparison">Which proxy network suits your business requirements best?</a></li>

<li><a href="#best_proxy_provider">The best  proxy providers</a></li>


Understanding internet service providers (ISPs)

An internet service provider (ISP) is a company that provides access to the internet, such as AT&T or Verizon. ISPs provide internet access through numerous means, including DSL, cable, wireless and fiber-optic connections.

When looking to buy ISP proxies or Residential proxies, you're being provided a proxy pool that contains ISP addresses. These IP addresses have a higher level of internet reputation since they appear as a home internet connection opposed to cloud hosting services.

<h2 id="isp">What are ISP Proxies?</h2>

Static Residential Proxies or ISP proxies are formed from IP addresses bought or leased from internet service providers. These proxy networks are hosted in data centers but appear like residential IPs and have datacenter proxy speeds. These proxies are typically better and more economical for high amounts of concurrent proxy connections on sites with low to medium blocking mechanisms.

More accurately, ISP proxies are created by having datacenter IP addresses routed by an ISP upstream carrier. These IPs are then announced by the ISP and appear under their autonomous system number (ASN), hence allowing them to appear as residential IPs.

Ultimately, proxy providers offering ISP proxies have essentially disguised datacenter proxies as authentic residential proxy IPs. Seems like the best of both worlds right? Unfortunately, it's not all sunshine and rainbows, next we'll cover the pros and cons of this unique proxy type.

<h2 id="isp_use_case">In-depth Analysis of ISP Proxies</h2>

Since internet service providers provision the IP addresses used for ISP proxies, they are not the perfect solution for all use cases. Below we'll discuss when to use ISP proxies and when to consider other proxy types for your business goals.

  • High speeds and uptime - ISP proxies are fast, reliable, and offer a stable internet connection. That's because they're hosted in data centers and aren't reliant on peer devices.
  • Difficult to detect - Anti-bot and IP monitoring system have a harder time detecting these IP addresses as they have a higher reputation than common cloud hosting IPs.
  • Bandwidth flexibility - ISP proxy providers typically offer unlimited bandwidth or cheaper rates than most residential proxy providers. These proxies provide you an economical way to run bandwidth-intensive operations.

Disadvantages of ISP proxies

  • Low IP diversity - Since ISP proxies operate similarly to datacenter proxies, they rely on a subnet model for their IP addresses. Thus they have the inability to offer a wide variety of unique IPs.
  • Fewer locations - ISP proxies rely on the proxy provider having servers in a physical location, making it difficult for them to offer many locations or unique countries.
  • Predictable IP providers - Since the IP addresses on the providers proxy server are allocated by an internet service provider, they're quite predictable if the internet service provider is a smaller local carrier.

ISP Proxies are Ideal For

  • Websites that require consistent user identity - Many websites require IP addresses of logged in sessions to remain consistent for avoiding IP bans. These proxy servers are ideal as static residential proxies can keep the same outgoing IP address.
  • Bandwidth intensive tasks - Unlike residential proxies, ISP proxies often have unlimited bandwidth making them the ideal solution for high bandwidth usage tasks.

ISP Proxies Use Cases

  • Performing online purchases - Online retailers have developed many anti-bot mechanisms to prevent purchase automations. ISP proxies are ideal for bypassing these mechanisms since they're harder to detect and have low latency.
  • Account management - Marketing professionals utilize ISP proxies to change their IP address for each account they manage. This provides them with a high reputation IP address that avoids account bans and the ability continuously use the same IP address.

Understanding Proxy Peers and End User Devices

Proxy peers, also known as end user proxy devices are individual peoples devices that are contributing their internet connection to a proxy server. These user devices are commonly sourced through Software Development Kits (SDKs) or earning apps, but there are also bad actors that source these devices in unethical manners. It's important for your business to trust the proxy providers it uses, as a provider that sources its proxy network unethically could harm your businesses reputation.

In further detail, these proxy peer devices are tied to a physical addresses of real people - their computers, mobile phones, or smart devices on Wi-Fi. These devices route traffic on behalf of proxy users, thus requests seem to be sent from residential IP addresses. The connection path when traffic is being routed through a residential device appears like the following: your device -> proxy server -> peer device -> web/URL.

Residential proxy providers offering residential proxies have essentially gather many contributing proxy peers together to perform requests on behalf of proxy users. These proxy networks are often considered the best quality proxies, but we'll go over some reasons why this is not the case for all use cases.

<h2 id="residential">What are Residential Proxies?</h2>

Residential proxies are a proxy network comprised of many proxy peers, often millions. These proxies are tied to real IP addresses on physical devices around the world. These IPs are supplied by internet service providers (ISPs) and are obtained by the physical device sharing access to its Wi-Fi or cellular connection. Since these proxy networks are comprised of real physical devices, their data retrieval times is often slower than other proxy types.

Customers of these residential proxy networks connect via a proxy server that allows for numerous IP accessing options and features; Some of these features include: static or sticky sessions, rotating IP addresses, geolocation filtering, and more. All these features provide the ability to customize your proxy solution based on the task requirements, thus making it nearly impossible to detect and block.

<h2 id="residential_use_case">In-Depth Analysis of Residential Proxies</h2>

Residential proxies are considered the 'cream of the crop' in the proxy and data gathering industry. Although they have high praise, they may not be the ideal solution for your needs which we'll discuss further.

Advantages of Residential Proxies

  • Large variety of locations - Due to the sheer amount of physical peer devices, these proxy networks allow for accessing nearly any geolocation.
  • Very large IP pool - Residential proxy servers can access up to millions of peer devices with different IP addresses. Due to the quantity and nature of IP rotation in these proxy networks, you'll rarely get the same IP twice.
  • Hard to block - Since residential proxies are formed by many unique internet connections around the world, the IP addresses often don't share subnet masks. Since there is no correlation between the peer IPs, it is difficult for anti-bot mechanisms to block.

Disadvantages of Residential Proxies

  • Shared proxy pool - Residential proxy providers provide access to the same network for all proxy customers, meaning you'll may have to share IPs with other users.
  • Slow speed - These proxies are significantly slower than ISP or datacenter proxies since they rely on the internet quality of a end user and add an extra element to the connection path.
  • Unpredictable connection - Even though proxy providers offer sticky sessions that let you keep the same IP for a duration of time, peer devices could disconnect at any moment.

Residential proxies are Ideal For

  • Location sensitive tasks - Residential proxies are fantastic at offering granular location options for localized content (country, state, city, zip code).
  • Websites with strict security mechanisms - Targets with strict anti-bot solutions have difficulty banning residential IPs due to their highly reputable appearance and large variety.

Residential Proxies Use Cases

  • E-commerce scraping - Residential proxies help businesses extract valuable market insights about product trends and pricing changes from platforms like Amazon or Walmart.
  • AI training - Artificial intelligence models need to be provided enormous amounts diverse data. Residential proxies can help gather localized information en masse to create accurate AI models.
  • SERP monitoring - Residential proxies provide marketing agencies the ability to scrape localized search results, track keyword positions, and analyze competitors.
  • Travel fare aggregation - Residential proxies offer flight and travel search engines the ability to consistently monitor travel agency offers while avoiding IP bans.

<h2 id="comparison">Comparing ISP Proxies vs Residential Proxies</h2>

ISP proxies are static residential proxies, whereas residential proxies are rotating proxies. When performing data-intensive tasks or requiring control over IP consistency, ISP proxies are ideal. On the other hand, if you need a highly diverse network of IPs or must circumvent strict anti-bot mechanisms, residential proxies have got you covered.

ISP proxies are IPs leased from internet service providers and placed among server in data centers. Alternatively, residential proxies are sourced from a proxy peers real IP address and internet connection.

In terms of speed and bandwidth, ISP proxies are the superior choice in both categories, though may not meet your needs of IP diversity or available locations.

When it comes to pricing, residential proxies are often the lower entry option of the two. ISP proxies will be cheaper for those who require high volumes of bandwidth, but residential proxy pricing often scales down with larger sized data commitments.

<table class="GeneratedTable">
   <th>Static Residential (ISP)</th>
   <td>Servers in data centers</td>
   <td>Physical peer devices</td>
   <td>Automatic and manual</td>
   <td>Private or shared</td>
   <th>Ideal For</th>
   <td>High bandwidth usage, low-medium security targets</td>
   <td>Specific geolocations required, high security targets</td>
<!-- Codes by -->

<h2 id="best_proxy_provider">Finding a Reputable Residential Proxy Provider</h2>
Hey, you're reading an article on a residential proxies provider website!

Massive offers a 100% ethically-sourced residential proxy network to scale your data collection with market-leading performance and pricing. Experience your true business potential using the Massive Network with a 3-day money-back guarantee.


Both ISP proxies and residential proxies are excellent choices along your web scraping journey, but have different strengths. All proxy types have unique attributes that you need to consider when performing data gathering tasks.

We sincerely hope that we provided an adequate guide that helped in the decision of what proxy type is best for your needs. If you're in search for a reliable proxy provider that is here to help your business succeed, reach out to us here!

Ready to get Started?

Experience 100% ethical web data collection with Massive’s advanced proxy solutions.

Sign Up Now

Read More